New York Judge finds girl can be sued for negligence for hitting elderly woman with her bike.

View all news posts

A New York State judge has ruled that 4-year-olds, racing bicycles with training wheels, can be sued for negligence for running down an elderly woman on a Manhattan sidewalk.

Judge Paul Wooten of the State Supreme Court in Manhattan dug way back to cases from 1928 to rule that the a personal injury suit filed by the family of Claire Menagh can proceed, The New York Times reported.

The suit alleges that in the spring of 2009 Juliet Breitman and Jacob Kohn, both 4, were racing their bikes on a sidewalk on East 52nd Street when Breitman stuck Menagh, 87.

Menagh was "seriously and severely injured," fractured a hip and died three months later of unrelated causes, the paper reported.

Her estate sued the children and their mothers, Dana Breitman and Rachel Kohn, who were supervising them at the time of the accident.

Defense attorneys have argued in trying to dismiss the suit that Juliet Breitman is too young to be negligent citing cases from 82 years ago that found children under the age of 4 are "conclusively presumed to be incapable of negligence."

However, Wooten ruled that the personal injury suit could continue because Juliet was three months shy of her fifth birthday when the accident occurred.

Attorneys at Ross Feller Casey, LLP have built a nationally recognized reputation for their impressive track record of victories in personal injury cases.

Noteworthy examples include:
• $85 million for a man who fractured his spine after falling through an open manhole
• $51 million verdict for a 4-year-old boy whose foot was torn off in a SEPTA escalator
• $36.4 million recovery for the family of a man killed in a Delaware oil refinery explosion
• $30 million recovery for a 10-year-old girl paralyzed by a defectively designed lap belt
• $29.5 million recovery in the Pier 34 collapse case
• $22.9 million recovery in a spinal cord injury case
• $22 million medical malpractice verdict for a brain injury during child birth
• $20.8 million verdict for an amputation injury
• $18.4 million verdict for a child who suffered a stroke
• $13 million recovery for a man who suffered a brain injury in a truck accident

To learn more, click Firm Overview

Disclaimer - Ross Feller Casey, LLP provides legal advice only after an attorney-client relationship is formed. Our website is an introduction to the firm and does not create a relationship between our attorneys and clients. An attorney-client relationship is formed only after a written agreement is signed by the client and the firm. Because every case is unique, the description of awards and summary of cases successfully handled are not intended to imply or guarantee that same success in other cases. Ross Feller Casey, LLP represents catastrophically injured persons and their families in injury and wrongful death cases, providing legal representation in Pennsylvania and New Jersey.

AS SEEN ON

  • NBC
  • CNN
  • ABC
  • CBS
  • AP
  • The Philadelphia Inquirer

Contact us for an initial consultation

If you would like a member of our staff to contact you for a free initial consultation on your case, please complete this form, or call us toll-free at 215-515-4401.

  • Ross Feller Casey, LLP One Liberty Place 1650 Market St, Suite 3450 Philadelphia, PA 19103

    This web site is designed for general information only. The information presented at this site should not be construed to be formal legal advice nor the formation of a lawyer/client relationship.

    Because every case is different, the description of awards and cases previously handled do not guarantee a similar outcome in current or future cases.

    Copyright © 2016 Ross Feller Casey, LLP